An analysis published on 22 November 2026 warned Namibian creators, radio stations and event organisers that America's fair use doctrine offers no defence under the country's copyright law.
According to The Namibian, the distinction matters whenever a broadcaster uses a song as a jingle, a DJ plays another artist's work or a producer adds music to online content. Namibia applies fair dealing, a narrower set of exceptions under the 1994 Copyright and Neighbouring Rights Protection Act.
Fair dealing is not the American fair use doctrine
Fair use has entered everyday discussion through American media and social platforms. In the United States, it gives courts a flexible test that can excuse an unauthorised use after a broad assessment of fairness.
Namibian law takes a different approach. Fair dealing provides a closed list of permitted purposes. A use that falls outside those categories can infringe copyright even when the project causes no obvious harm, makes no money or credits the artist.
The Namibian's analysis put the position plainly:
Strictly speaking, “fair use” does not exist in Namibian law.
A Wikipedia overview of fair dealing describes the same basic distinction across legal systems that use the doctrine: the defence cannot apply to an act outside the enumerated categories. For Namibian users, the first question is therefore whether the purpose is permitted, not whether the use feels reasonable.
What does Namibia's copyright law allow?
The act permits fair dealing for research, private study and personal, private use. A musician may copy a song at home to examine its chord progression, but uploading that copy to a public channel or distributing it removes the private setting on which the exception depends.
Criticism and review can also qualify. A music journalist assessing a new album may use a short clip to support that critique. Reporting current events receives protection in newspapers, broadcasts and films, allowing a news crew to include music heard in the background while covering a public rally.
The law further permits limited quotations and the use of a work as a teaching example, provided the amount is reasonable for that purpose. These exceptions support education, public debate and journalism without giving producers a general licence to reuse creative work.
Qualifying by purpose is only the first step. The dealing itself must still be fair. Identifying the author and source is mandatory when an exception applies, but attribution does not create an exception where none exists.
There is no 10-second or four-bar rule
Two widely repeated shortcuts have no basis in Namibian law: the claim that using fewer than 10 seconds is safe, and the belief that copying no more than four bars avoids infringement. The Namibian found no such automatic protection in the act.
That absence makes a rights check more important, not less. A brief opening jingle can still require permission when its purpose is to brand or introduce a programme rather than to review, report or study the music.
Comparative guidance illustrates why context matters. Emily Carr University's copyright guide says fairness assessments can consider the purpose and character of copying, along with the amount used and the importance of the excerpt to the whole work. That guidance should not be treated as a statement of Namibian law, but it shows why duration alone cannot settle the issue.
Free distribution and artist credit do not settle permission
Non-commercial distribution is not automatically lawful. Uploading a video to YouTube without charging viewers, or playing music at a free community event, does not by itself convert an infringing use into fair dealing.
Credit serves a different function. Naming an artist acknowledges authorship and can satisfy an attribution condition attached to an applicable exception. It does not replace consent for a promotional reel, programme theme or other use outside the statutory categories.
For creators building a business, this distinction belongs in basic financial planning. Music clearance, written permissions and records of the purpose behind each excerpt can be reviewed before publication, rather than after a channel attracts advertising or a sponsor.
Weak enforcement is not legal certainty
Few Namibian court decisions testing these provisions may help explain the confidence surrounding informal rules. The Namibian suggested that limited litigation could reflect the time and money required to bring a case, rather than an absence of rights worth enforcing.
That creates uncertainty on both sides. Artists may struggle to afford enforcement, while producers cannot treat years of unchallenged practice as proof that their use is lawful. Greater commercial success can change the calculation by giving a rights holder a stronger reason to seek legal advice.
The analysis expressed concern about that outcome but also welcomed the possibility of judicial clarification. Clearer decisions would help everyday users understand the boundaries of the act and give creators firmer ground when negotiating payment for their work.
For now, the practical test is sequential: identify the statutory purpose, assess whether the dealing is fair, meet the attribution requirement and obtain permission when the use does not qualify. A programme director who cannot complete that check has a legal and commercial risk to resolve before broadcast.
Frequently asked questions
Does fair use apply in Namibia?
No. Namibia's 1994 Copyright and Neighbouring Rights Protection Act uses fair dealing, which limits exceptions to specified purposes. The broader American fair use doctrine is not a defence under Namibian law.
Can a radio station use a short song clip as a jingle?
Length alone does not make the use lawful. Namibia has no automatic 10-second or four-bar exemption, so a station should establish an applicable fair dealing exception or obtain the owner's permission.
Is non-commercial use always fair dealing?
No. A free upload or free community event does not automatically qualify. The use must fit a permitted category and remain fair, while credit to the artist does not replace permission.
