A N$19.8 billion German offer to settle colonial crimes in Namibia faces renewed scrutiny over reparations, community representation and a pending court challenge, scholar Henning Melber warned on 21 November 2026.
Writing in The Namibian, Melber examined a 23 October meeting organised after the Forum of German-Speaking Namibians was invited to discuss “Towards Demystifying and Finalising the Genocide Apology and Reparations Process”. His commentary challenges the pressure to conclude the joint declaration negotiated by the German and Namibian governments before the end of the year.
What the joint declaration offers Namibia
The meeting, attended by members of indigenous communities, served as a platform for the Genocide Apology and Reparation Technical Team involved in the bilateral negotiations. Participants urged Namibia’s president to adopt the joint declaration, commonly called the JD.
Melber describes the proposal as a transactional arrangement: 1.05 billion euros, equivalent to N$19.8 billion, in return for settling German colonial crimes, including genocide. The declaration contains a German apology and states that Namibia’s government and people accept it.
“The Namibian government and its people accept Germany’s apology. This shall close the painful chapter of the past.”
For Melber, that attempt to close the chapter amounts to “reconciliation lite”. His objection concerns the legal and political finality of the wording, rather than the value of public investment.
Reparations or development finance?
Hoze Riruako, chief of one Ovaherero Traditional Authority faction, repeatedly used the term reparations at the meeting. The word also appears in the event title and the technical team’s full name.
Germany, however, categorically rejects reparations, according to Melber. The JD does not use the term. It instead proposes a “reconstruction and development programme” for seven regions where descendants of the affected indigenous communities mainly live.
That distinction matters beyond terminology. It shapes whether the agreement is understood as a legal response to genocide or as a development package negotiated between two governments.
Forum chairman Harald Hecht presented the financial offer as a missed opportunity if it were not accepted. He calculated that it would provide about N$900 million annually for 23 years, supporting land redistribution, schools, training, water and energy supplies in the seven regions.
The comparison with current spending is stark. Namibia’s budget allocates slightly less than N$500 million a year to land reform, roughly half the proposed annual German contribution. Melber nevertheless points to land reform’s weak results and notes that beneficiaries have often excluded people whose ancestors originally occupied the land.
Who can speak for affected communities?
Claims at the meeting that attendees represented all descendants of affected indigenous communities collide with an active legal dispute. In January 2023, 11 claimants from the other Ovaherero Traditional Authority faction and the Nama Traditional Leaders Association challenged the JD negotiations in the High Court.
They argued that the process violated the motion submitted in September 2006 by the late paramount chief Kuaima Riruako. At the first hearing in November 2025, the court admitted another 24 traditional authorities as applicants, bringing the number of indigenous agencies involved to 35.
Melber argues that signing the JD while that case remains pending would be tantamount to contempt of court. He also disputes the technical team’s claim to represent communities directly, because its members were not nominated as their representatives.
Before his motion was adopted, Riruako set out a different role for the state.
“The Namibian government should be an interested party in any discussions between its nationals and the German government on the issue of reparations.”
That formulation places affected communities at the negotiating table, with government involved rather than substituted for them. Charles Eiseb, a leading technical team member, offered a contrasting view of participation.
“Don’t go and claim that someone is excluded just because you cannot sit in the front table.”
For Melber, the front table is precisely where Riruako wanted indigenous communities to sit.
Reconciliation requires more than money
The commentary also turns to the responsibilities of German-speaking Namibians. Melber describes restorative justice as a shared culture of repair and commemoration involving descendants of both colonisers and colonised communities.
He argues that white German-speaking Namibians remain beneficiaries of colonialism and constitute a privileged, affluent minority. People of European ancestry make up about 5% of Namibia’s population, according to Encyclopedia Britannica, although that broader category is not limited to German speakers.
Hecht stressed that forum members were fourth-generation Namibians. Melber responds that declarations of loyalty to “One Namibia, One Nation” and “Unity in Diversity” do not, by themselves, demonstrate accountability.
He reports hearing no personal acknowledgement of implication in colonial privilege, apology, atonement or visible remorse from white German-speaking participants. One white speaker concluded, “we are ending the colonial mentality”.
Melber’s own position adds context to that criticism. He arrived in Namibia in 1967 as the teenage son of West German emigrants, joined Swapo in 1974 and returned his membership in 2025 over the party’s continued justification of human rights violations in exile. He is affiliated with the Nordic Africa Institute in Uppsala and holds extraordinary professorships at the University of Pretoria and the University of the Free State.
The immediate policy choice therefore extends beyond whether N$900 million a year would help underserved regions. It also concerns who has authority to accept an apology, whether development finance can settle genocide claims, and how a final agreement can proceed while 35 indigenous agencies are before the High Court.
Frequently asked questions
How much would Germany provide under the joint declaration?
The proposal totals 1.05 billion euros, or N$19.8 billion. Forum chairman Harald Hecht presented this as about N$900 million annually over 23 years for development in seven regions.
Does the agreement use the word reparations?
No. According to Henning Melber, Germany rejects that term and the JD instead provides for a reconstruction and development programme.
Why is community representation disputed?
A High Court challenge begun in January 2023 now involves 35 indigenous agencies. Melber argues that the government technical team is not direct representation by representatives nominated by the affected communities.
